Rich or King? Growing a Firm by Getting Out of the Way, with AJ Ayers (Author Chats)

Should a founder be rich or king? AJ Ayers faced that question while building Brooklyn Fi into a fully remote RIA nearing $1 billion, and her answer was to hand off all 120 of her own clients so she could lead the firm. Noam Wasserman's The Founder's Dilemmas helped her get there, and Traction gave her and co-founder Shane Mason an operating rhythm from year one.

For advisors, there's plenty to take back to the office. AJ makes the case that investing is "solved" and communication is what sets great firms apart. She walks through keeping the client experience consistent as the team grows, and she has a pointed message for founders who say their associates aren't ready: give them a few at-bats first. She's also candid about the role luck played, having picked equity compensation right before the IPO wave of 2020 and 2021.

Then we get into her new book, Creative Money, written for people who avoid personal finance altogether. We talk about the ten years behind her "overnight" book deal, the three budgets, the financial triage plan Brooklyn Fi uses with clients, and how she's using the book to help grow the firm. We close on the Nick Murray book she thinks every advisor should revisit.

In this episode

  • How a high school bookstore job and a Steven Millhauser novel led AJ to Skidmore, publishing, and eventually financial planning

  • Why she thinks investing is "solved" and communication is what sets great firms apart (and why English majors should become CFPs)

  • The FIRE-era books behind her investing philosophy, and how Brooklyn Fi keeps the client experience consistent as it scales (aiming for 75%, not 100%)

  • Impostor syndrome as a career changer, and running Traction/EOS since year one

  • The Founder's Dilemmas, rich vs. king, handing off all 120 of her clients, and giving associates their at-bats

  • Approaching $1 billion: organic vs. inorganic growth, and her "bias for action"

  • Why she wrote Creative Money, how the book deal came together, and using the book as a business development tool

  • The three budgets, the financial triage plan, and when Brooklyn Fi knew it was working

Books mentioned

Notable quotes

"Most personal finance books are written for people who already like finance." — AJ Ayers, on who she wrote Creative Money for

"You haven't let them have any at-bats, so give them five at bats and then decide that they're not ready." — AJ Ayers, on founders who say their associates can't take on clients or sales calls

"We think about our clients all the time. They don't think about us very often." — AJ Ayers, on what Nick Murray's Simple Wealth, Inevitable Wealth taught her about the advisor's job

Chapters

  • (00:00) Intro

  • (00:34) Welcome, and how AJ finds time to sleep

  • (01:15) Who is AJ: from creatives in Brooklyn to equity compensation

  • (02:39) How reading shaped her life: a bookstore job, Steven Millhauser, and Skidmore

  • (04:16) Why communication is the job, and why English majors should become CFPs

  • (05:22) The books behind her investing philosophy

  • (07:15) Keeping the philosophy consistent as the team scales

  • (08:45) Impostor syndrome, and knowing when to get out of the way

  • (10:30) Running Traction/EOS from year one

  • (12:15) The Founder's Dilemmas: rich or king

  • (13:41) Handing off every client, and giving associates their at-bats

  • (16:13) Approaching $1 billion: organic vs. inorganic growth

  • (18:46) Why write a book?

  • (20:30) The power of a niche, and the luck of the IPO wave

  • (22:05) The book as a business development tool

  • (23:47) How to write a book, and the ten years behind the deal

  • (26:37) The three budgets and the financial triage plan

  • (28:26) When Brooklyn Fi knew it was working

  • (29:44) Reading now: The Tainted Cup and P.G. Wodehouse

  • (31:07) Lightning round

  • (31:54) The one book everyone in wealth management should read

  • (32:46) Where to find Creative Money and AJ

About the guest

AJ Ayers, CFP®, is co-founder and CEO of Brooklyn Fi, a fully remote RIA she launched with Shane Mason in 2018 that specializes in equity compensation planning for tech employees, founders, and creatives. Before becoming a planner, she was a music journalist and worked her way up through book publishing as an editor. She is the author of Creative Money: New Financial Rules for Artists, Innovators, and Misfits (Tarcher/Penguin Random House, 2026), writes the Substack newsletter Money Changes Everything, and co-hosts the podcast The Liquidity Event. Her writing has appeared in The New York Times, New York Magazine, and The Wall Street Journal.

Connect with AJ

Next
Next

Follow the Crazies: Spotting the Next Shift in Financial Planning, with Bob Veres (Author Chats)